There were even two different kinds of criticism to be had.
Constructive criticism; destructive criticism.
My father, a university professor, provided the constructive kind of criticism. No matter what you'd done, whether passing a test, completing a paper, or what-have-you, there was always a slightly better and more interesting way to have finished the project.
"You know, if you had written about x, y and z this paper would have really been even more interesting..."Though he meant well, the net effect was deflating: nothing was ever quite good enough. Even though I got almost all "A's," got into a top university, graduated with honors, and didn't get arrested or pregnant, somehow I mostly felt like a disappointment. He didn't mean to have that effect. It just happened.
My mother, on the other hand, was also a college instructor. She provided the destructive criticism.
"And how much do you weigh?"
or
"Nobody wants to hear your opinion on that!"
or
"What makes you think you're good enough to [fill in the blank]?"One learned to tread lightly and skitter around the edges of the room when she was in a mood. If her eyes happened to light upon you when she was feeling out-of-sorts, you were guaranteed a sniping shot or two.
So, with all of that in the background, finishing my master's degree at age 51 was quite the accomplishment. When I sent off the dissertation a few months ago, I felt really pleased with the quality of my work, particularly in light of my fairly tumultuous life over the last couple of years -- moving house, moving country for that matter -- three different times. Blah blah blah. You know that drill; I've bored you with it all before.
On Friday night, I couldn't sleep, so I came downstairs and began opening the mail.
"Oooo! A letter from Leicester!"
I tore open the envelope, only to read the following first sentence:
"Overall this is a disappointing piece of work..."I'll spare you the rest, and cut to the chase: I did pass. Not with distinction, as I'd hoped, but with ... disappointment. How ironic that just two days before, I'd been defending Mr. London Street against spurious charges of being quite disappointing. Now I was damned disappointing myself. Oh, the shame! The shame!
Damn, damn. And bloody hell. So much for a glittering career in Academe. A good thing, probably, that I didn't get all this quite critical feedback at age 24, because I'm sure I would have slit my own throat back then, and here you'd be now, with no blog to read. Still, there are a few positive take-aways from my critical bloodbath: the dissertation was apparently well-written and easy to read, and it provided some useful conclusions for management.
And it was a "Pass." I'll take it, thanks very much.
Back to my regular duties: dusting, playing tennis, and destroying the ozone layer through excessive consumption of international flights. At least I know my skill-set.
















